Paulie Gee's Slice Shop

Alison Pouw· 5 months ago

such a lovely little neighborhood classic. the sesame crust is standout and the pepperoni hot honey is out of this world. i’m not usually a thick crust girly but they do it so well that you have no choice but to love it. we had 5 people and couldn’t finish one pizza. super filling and delicious. generous on the pep too. mikes hot honey is the perfect touch. great for a game night or serving lots of guests.

Jaye Aster Broder· 3 months ago

I went to this slice shop excited to try the Hellboy slice squared. I was surprised to see a pizza shop with a C health rating but even more surprised to see this odd print out above it implying that the restaurant was in some sort of queue. The restaurant’s signage is confusing given the inspection timeline. NYC Health Department's ABCEats inspections took place less than a month after the initial November 18 violations in 2024. As of June 2026 inspections, according to the lookup tool, the restaurant still has a C health rating for “Evidence of mice or live mice in establishment's food or non-food areas” as well as other issues. I did appreciate that the restaurant had vegan options for the Hellboy, Vidalia, and Freddy slice options.

Travis St.Marthe· 2 months ago

Amazing crust and a good tasting pepperoni. Cheese and sauce was mid, not as good as it used to be. You can see from the other reviews, someone’s doing a terrible job distributing the pepperoni. Kinda reminded me of the blueberry scene from Casino. Line can get long at times which some people voiced their displeasure about.

Natalie Bennett· 4 months ago

Classic pizza shop. I did enjoy seeing some of the relics from the past like the old cash register in the back. I had a pepperoni slice and a regular cheese slice. The cheese was decent. The pepperoni was a bit salty to me.

Michael Serra· 3 months ago

I’ve been to Paulie G’s Slice Shop four times now, and they are easily one of the best pizza spots I’ve had in a long time. As a vegan, it’s refreshing to find a place that doesn't just offer an 'afterthought' slice. They have a full range of vegan options, and I’ve genuinely enjoyed every single one. The crust is the star here, it has that perfect, traditional, old-school New York texture. One slice even features sesame seeds on the crust, which adds an incredible, unique depth of flavor that I haven't found anywhere else. It’s the perfect marriage of nostalgic, classic pizza quality with modern, thoughtful plant-based ingredients. Whether you’re vegan or not, this place is a must-visit.

Reviews and ratings powered by Google. See all reviews for Paulie Gee's Slice Shop on Google Maps