Gargiulo's

Adam Azim· 4 months ago

The world in general is a rough place, and Brooklyn is just as rough. But it’s made all the better by the likes of Gargiulo’s. I had their Caesar salad and risotto. And to put it simply, it was all authentic in an age of authenticity. And our server was also a really cool cat. I don’t know if I’ll ever end up in Coney Island again, but if I do, I wouldn’t mind making another trip to Gargiulo’s for some authentic Italian food and friendly service.

Jesus Garcia· 3 months ago

I have been going to Gargiulo's from time to time my whole life. Graduating dinners from Elementary and High school, Retirement dinners (this last time) and just going on a regular basis. I have always loved this restaurant and I recommend it to everyone, especially now that they have way more parking and valet!!! 😁🫡👍❤️

MC Productions NJ· 4 months ago

Gargiulo’s Restaurant was a wonderful venue for a christening celebration. We had the pleasure of capturing both photography and video there, and the experience was excellent from beginning to end. The staff provided great service, the food was delicious, and the space had a warm, elegant feel for a family celebration. One of our favorite details was the beautiful natural light on the dance floor, which made the moments feel even more special and photographed beautifully. A great location for anyone planning a christening, family event, or milestone celebration.

Silvio The Wolf· 3 months ago

So the food looked good. The bread was decent, the pasta was probably the only thing I would say was delicious. They put a dish of veggies on the table that was flavorless. My pasta fagioli was very much not gourmet at all, it was almost like if you ordered it from a high school cafeteria. I couldn’t eat more than half, I make better at home in 10 mins than that. My mother ordered Chicken Francese, but instead of a lemon wine sauce, they just smothered it in brown gravy. She sent it back. The waiter said that’s just how they make it. I’ve never seen that. I got a chicken Caesar salad. The salad was good, but the chicken had little flavor. As for dessert, I got the coconut ice cream. That was alright but nothing special. I heard the tiramisu was pretty basic as well from the others at my table. The waiter was a nice guy, attentive and entertaining. The owner greeted us at the end, which was nice. Very old school, that. But the atmosphere was a little rambunctious. Not the dining hall itself, but there were 3 proms happening in the other room so the music was blasting and kids kept screaming. The overall experience could have been better. I can’t say I would go back.

Walter Moffat· a month ago

Very clean and updated. Price fair not overpriced. But!! I was very taken back when I asked for pasta as a side and it was not available. Not even as an upcharge. If you wanted pasta you needed to order a plate of pasta . I found out that that's the way they've been doing things forever; for me it was not what I expected. There is another restaurant in Brooklyn that does the same thing will not name names but they've been around for 100 years as well ...sorry I won't be going back to that plac. I would love to come back to your restaurant but it would be nice to have a bowl of pasta as a side dish even as an upcharge. I would understand that. The gravy there is what you go out to dinner for at an Italian restaurant. Food was good!

Reviews and ratings powered by Google. See all reviews for Gargiulo's on Google Maps