Carmine's

Elvis Jimenez· 3 months ago

A Williamsburg Gem for Pizza and Beyond! ​If you are looking for an authentic neighborhood joint that hits all the right notes, Carmine’s Pizzeria in Williamsburg is an absolute must-visit. While it has a classic, welcoming Brooklyn energy, they offer way more than just your standard slice. ​Right off the bat, I was thrilled to find that they sell traditional Italian ice cream (gelato) and a wonderful selection of Italian cookies—perfect for treating your sweet tooth after a savory meal. But the real star of the show is their incredible selection of square pizzas. They have a large variety of thick-crust squares loaded with all kinds of creative, mouthwatering flavors. ​My absolute favorite of the day was the lasagna square. It was spectacular—perfectly crispy on the bottom, incredibly tasty, and just full of rich, authentic flavor in every single bite. Between the sweet treats, the massive variety, and that perfect lasagna slice, Carmine’s has officially earned a spot on my go-to list. Whether you're a local or just passing through the neighborhood, do yourself a favor and drop in for a square!

Gil cosenza· 5 months ago

Had our St. Francis of Paola grammar school reunion luncheon at Carmine’s. The Food was outstanding. Service was amazing. We are already planning for our next St Francis of Paola Class of 1977 Reunion. Thank You, Carmine for your warm hospitality .

CAMI FILMS· a year ago

I came here because I just wanted another spot to try. The penne vodka pizza was easily a 9/10. The pepperoni was a strong 7/10. So I rate my overall experience here a 8/10. Very very good pizza. Crunchy and tasty. I would def come back here again.

Christopher Taveras· 4 months ago

slices a lil small for the price ngl but hey we’re in Williamsburg 🤣 Don’t get the chicken broccoli Sicilian I nearly had chicken that slice gets a 2/10 Pepperoni slice flavor was great but a lil small for the price ngl 9.5/10 Overall score 8.5/10

Matt Middleton· 5 months ago

Excellent pizza. Great tomato sauce, caramelized crust, and freshly made. I never saw my dog on its hind legs until she got a whiff of Carmines. Will definitely be back

Reviews and ratings powered by Google. See all reviews for Carmine's on Google Maps